On this day in 2009, a Broward County jury returned a $300 million verdict against Philip Morris USA for Lucinda “Cindy” Naugle. It was Kelley | Uustal’s very first Engle tobacco trial, and at the time, the largest verdict in any Engle Progeny case tried in Florida.
These tobacco cases grew out of a Florida class action against the tobacco industry. In 2006, the Florida Supreme Court decertified the class but let key findings stand, opening the door for thousands of former smokers and their families to bring their own cases.
Cindy was one of them. She picked up her first cigarette in 1968, at 20. After trying to quit for decades, Naugle finally succeeded in the early 1990s, once the nicotine patch became available. Unfortunately, by then, the damage was done: in 1993, she was diagnosed with emphysema and suffered from COPD. At 61, she traveled in a wheelchair with oxygen around the clock.
Bob Kelley, Todd Falzone and their team showed the jury that Philip Morris concealed what it knew: that cigarettes were addictive and that they caused disease. During the trial, Cindy herself was a powerful witness. After the seven step walk to the witness stand, she needed five minutes to catch her breath. Early in the trial, Bob asked her a simple question:
Bob Kelley: Do you remember a time in your life when cigarette companies said that smoking was not addictive and that there was no proof that it caused any diseases?
Cindy Naugle: I remember a time, yes, many times.
Bob Kelley: And did you smoke cigarettes during that time?
Cindy Naugle: Yes.
Bob Kelley: Did you believe what they told you?
Cindy Naugle: I believed what they told me. Why would they make something if they thought it was going to kill me?
Bob Kelley: Why did you believe them?
Cindy Naugle: I just didn’t think they would make something that would kill millions of people, or make us sick.
Within hours of closing arguments, the jury returned its verdict: $56.6 million for her pain, suffering and medical expenses, and $244 million in punitive damages to punish Philip Morris and deter future misconduct. The jury attributed 10% of the fault to Cindy. The verdict was covered by NBC, ABC, 60 Minutes and The New York Times.
“The cigarette companies managed to hide the truth about their product for a long time, but the truth is out now,” said Bob Kelley, after the verdict.
The fight didn’t end there, and the trial judge later reduced the punitive damages to $36.8 million. On appeal, the Fourth District Court of Appeal upheld Philip Morris’s liability but sent the amount to a new jury, who again sided with Cindy for a lesser amount.
Cindy passed away on November 1, 2013, before she could receive the lung transplant the award would have made possible. Her testimony still captures what these cases are about: people who trusted a company that knew better.
Seventeen years later, Kelley | Uustal’s continues that fight, and the standard remains the same: when corporations put profit ahead of people, we make them answer for it. Read the full case story →
About Kelley | Uustal
Kelley | Uustal Trial Attorneys is a personal injury and trial law firm with a national reputation for handling catastrophic injury, wrongful death, medical malpractice, and product liability cases. The firm has secured hundreds of millions of dollars in verdicts and settlements on behalf of clients who have suffered life-altering injuries at the hands of corporations and institutions.
Kelley | Uustal Trial Attorneys represents companies, founders, shareholders, and executives in high-stakes commercial litigation, handling disputes involving breach of contract, partnership and shareholder conflicts, business torts, fraud and misrepresentation, professional negligence, lender liability, and other complex commercial claims.
For more information, visit kelleyuustal.com.