Not necessarily. The tobacco industry knew far more than what was revealed in the initial warnings. These warnings were not voluntary, but required by the government. And those warnings don’t give them immunity to target children for a deadly addiction, and then defend themselves by saying the addicts should have quit when they became adults. That may reduce the fault assigned to the tobacco company, but it is not a get out of jail free card. In addition, the warnings did little to counteract the tobacco industry’s sales tactics. For example, almost all of the tobacco companies sold cigarettes with “filters” even though the filters do not actually reduce any health risk. They sold “light” or “mild” cigarettes even though those were just as harmful to smokers as the “regulars.” And the industry hired scientists and spokespersons to publicly cast doubt on the warnings.